Is Your Business Coach Just Giving You Theory? 5 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

Is Your Business Coach Just Giving You Theory? 5 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

by Daniel Richards in Dan's Blog

You've read the books, attended the webinars, and listened to all the podcasts. You're ready to hire a business coach to take your company to the next level. But you're worried. You've heard stories about coaches who offer nothing but generic, theoretical advice that sounds great in a conference room but falls apart the second you try to apply it.

The truth is, not all coaches are created equal. Many lack the real-world, "battle-tested" experience needed to guide you through the chaos of building a business. They can give you a lot of theory, but what you really need is a proven system.

So, before you sign on the dotted line, here are five crucial questions to ask to ensure your potential coach can offer more than just textbook wisdom.

 

1. What specific systems and frameworks do you use?

A great coach doesn’t just show up with a grab-bag of ideas. They should have a proven, repeatable system. This shows they have a structured process that has worked for others and isn't just making it up as they go along.

  • What to look for: A clear explanation of their process. For example, my coaching is built around four core pillars: clarity, accountability, empowerment, and systems. I can show you exactly how we'll work through each of these to achieve your goals.

 

2. What is your real-world business experience?

Theory is one thing; hands-on experience is another. A coach who has actually built, managed, and even failed in a business has a deeper level of empathy and understanding. They know the difference between a good idea and a practical, profitable solution.

  • What to look for: A coach who can share specific stories from their own career. Ask them about their biggest failure and what they learned from it. Their answer will tell you more than a dozen glowing testimonials.

 

3. Can you show me a client success story or case study?

Testimonials are great, but a detailed case study is even better. It proves that the coach's methods are not just theoretical concepts. A good case study outlines a specific problem, the strategy used, and the quantifiable results achieved.

  • What to look for: A coach who can provide specific, measurable results. Don't settle for "we helped them grow." Ask, "We helped them increase their revenue by 40% in six months by implementing our accountability framework."

 

4. How do you measure progress and hold me accountable?

A great coach is a partner, not just a consultant. They don't just give you advice and walk away. They should have a clear process for setting goals, measuring outcomes, and keeping you on track.

  • What to look for: A clear plan for accountability. This might include regular check-ins, key performance indicators (KPIs), or a system for tracking your progress toward your business goals.

 

5. What is your philosophy on failure and setbacks?

Business isn't a straight line to success. There will be setbacks. A good coach has a perspective on how to handle these moments and use them as learning opportunities, not just as failures.

  • What to look for: A coach who shows they understand that challenges are part of the journey and has a strategy for navigating them. This reveals their resilience and will give you confidence that they can support you through tough times.

Before you hire a business coach, be a smart consumer. Ask these five questions to find a coach with real-world, "battle-tested" experience who can offer a proven system, not just generic advice. Your business deserves a partner who can give you the tools and insights you need to truly succeed.

Previous Post Next Post

Related Posts

How an Org Chart Empowers Your Small Business to Grow

How an Org Chart Empowers Your Small Business to Grow

As a small business owner, you’re used to chaos. Your team members wear many hats, the days are a whirlwind, and everyone just knows what to do, right? But what if I told you that the secret to scaling your business and creating a thriving culture isn't another marketing strategy or a new software system? It’s a simple organisational chart. It's surprising how many small businesses operate without a clear org structure. When I ask owners why, I often hear, "We’re small, and everyone wears multiple hats," or "We don't want to look too corporate." But how can you expect your team to understand where they fit into the bigger picture if you can't even provide them with a simple chart? Without clarity, you risk confusion, duplication of effort, and a lack of accountability. Providing a clear structure is the first step toward empowering your team and preparing your business for future growth. Step 1: Create Your "Right Now" Org Chart Your first step is to create a living, breathing document that reflects your current business structure. This isn't just about names and job titles; it's about defining roles, responsibilities, and reporting lines. List Every Role: Start by listing every single role needed to run your business, from marketing to operations. Assign Names: Place your team members' names next to their core roles. Acknowledge the "Hat Wearers": If a team member is covering multiple roles, simply put their name next to each one. This provides immediate clarity on their responsibilities. For non-core roles that you plan to fill in the future, use the word "placeholder" next to their name. This shows your team that their multi-faceted role is temporary and that you have a plan to hire more support as the business grows. Once your org chart is complete, share it with your team. Consider having one-on-one discussions with key team members first, then present it to the broader group. Emphasise that this is a live document—it should be updated as roles and responsibilities evolve. Step 2: Build the Org Structure for the Future Now that your team has clarity on their current roles, it's time to give them something to strive for. What does your business look like in 3 to 5 years? Creating a future org chart allows you to: Identify Growth Opportunities: Show your team what roles they could potentially grow into. This provides a clear career path and motivates them to develop their skills. Inform Personal Development Plans (PDPs): By seeing the future structure, team members can identify skills they need to learn to prepare for new roles. This makes their personal development plans more targeted and meaningful. Step 3: Communicate Your Vision With a clear org structure for both the present and the future, you can now effectively communicate your business's short-term and long-term plans. When your team understands where the business is headed and how their individual roles play a vital part, you will be amazed at the cultural shift that occurs. Clarity creates a sense of purpose. It replaces the feeling of just "doing a job" with the understanding that every action, every decision, and every role is contributing to a collective goal. This is how small businesses move from surviving to thriving. What's holding you back from creating your org chart today? Book your free 15 minute discovery call here. Org Chart Example only

The Gold Coast Growth Trap: Why Your $1M Business Needs More Than Just a Vision

The Gold Coast Growth Trap: Why Your $1M Business Needs More Than Just a Vision

You started your business on the Gold Coast with a dream. Maybe you saw a gap in the market, had a passion you wanted to share, or simply wanted the freedom to be your own boss. You’ve worked relentlessly, and it’s paid off—you’re doing $1M, $5M, even $10M in revenue. Congratulations, you're a success story. But as you’ve grown, the dream has started to feel like a trap. You’re working harder than ever, putting in nights and weekends, and the vision that once excited you is now buried under a mountain of daily tasks. You've hit the Gold Coast Growth Trap: the belief that working harder will fix everything. It couldn't be further from the truth. The reason most small businesses stop growing isn't a lack of opportunity; it's a breakdown of what happens inside the business. You either lose clarity on the destination, or you fail to empower your team to get you there. As a small business owner, it’s not about working harder—it’s about building a team that works smarter. Clarity: The First Step Out of the Trap Think of your business as a boat on the Broadwater. You, the owner, are the captain. Without a clear destination, your crew will row in different directions, burn valuable energy, and get nowhere fast. Clarity is your first step to getting unstuck. It means providing your team with a crystal-clear understanding of where you want to take the company. This isn't just a broad mission statement on your website; it's a specific, measurable plan that everyone understands. When you define the destination and the path to get there, you're no longer just managing a team—you’re leading a purpose-driven crew. Empowerment: Unleashing Your Team's Potential With clarity established, the next step is empowerment. You’re a Gold Coast business owner, not a micromanager. Yet, too many leaders fall into the trap of believing they have to do it all themselves. They become the bottleneck, holding back their team and, ultimately, their business. Empowerment is about giving your team the tools, trust, and authority they need to be successful on their own. It's about building a team that doesn't just wait for instructions but takes initiative, solves problems, and owns their outcomes. When you empower your team, you're not just delegating tasks; you're building a group of leaders who are invested in the company's success. This is how you transition from being the "fixer" to being the visionary. From Hard Work to Smart Systems There is nothing better than being able to pick your kids up from school and not be stressed about what's "not" being done at work. This kind of freedom isn't a pipe dream—it's a direct result of building a high-performance team. It all starts with clarity, which then enables you to empower your team. From there, you hold them accountable and implement the systems that allow you to scale your business without having to work around the clock. The good news? You likely already have all the pieces ready to go. You just need some help putting them together faster and more effectively. That's where I come in—to help you, the founder, owner, or small business leader, build the team that makes your business vision a reality.

Leave a comment

Contact form

Home Search Cart About